Whose rats are they anyway?
That’s the query on the heart of an escalating authorized battle between William Gottlieb Actual Property and fashion designer Donna Karan.
The 2 sides have traded lawsuits centered on City Zen, the Manhattan boutique owned by the designer at 705 Greenwich Road, and the vacant lot subsequent door, No. 703, owned by an affiliate of William Gottlieb Actual Property.
The rat infestation affecting each properties got here into the general public eye in June, when Karan’s boutique filed a suit against the Gottlieb affiliate. The proprietor of the vacant lot was negligent in permitting the infestation to develop, City Zen argued, which posed a public well being menace.
An outdated tree stump, rubble and particles on the vacant lot created “burrowing channels” that allowed rats to entry the City Zen property, in line with the shop. A dumpster on the lot created “a persistent and constantly replenished meals supply” for rodents, in line with the grievance.
“Each worker, shopper, visitor, and member of the general public who enters the Premises is in danger,” City Zen stated in its grievance.
A visit by The Real Deal’s video team at nightfall certainly confirmed the presence of rats.
The allegations paint an image in stark distinction to the high-end attire model, with places within the Hamptons and Palm Seaside, the place cashmere sweatpants go for $1,395 and suede rompers are advertised at $3,495.
It appeared like the 2 sides possible might and would resolve the difficulty out of court docket. However Gottlieb as a substitute fired again a couple of weeks later. The property proprietor launched its personal go well with, this time naming Karan as a defendant.
The situation of the City Zen constructing is exacerbating and sustaining the rat — or “rodent harborage” — drawback, whereas presumably contributing to steer contamination on the lot. The partitions of the constructing create a severe “danger of particles falling from above.”
“[T]he deteriorated cavities, voids, openings and different situations inside and alongside the outside of the 705 Constructing present or contribute to rodent harborage,” the Gottlieb LLC wrote in its grievance.
An inspection report supplied to The Actual Deal and signed by an engineer highlights unsafe situations and visual holes within the City Zen constructing. The report, performed by the agency R Cladding Consulting and Engineering employed to examine the Gottlieb property, notes a number of the masonry within the City Zen constructing has “deteriorated” and is unsafe.
A Division of Buildings inspector has to this point not issued any violations for the facade.
“Donna Karan’s constructing is unsafe and riddled with rat holes,” Jordan Barowitz, a spokesperson for William Gottlieb Actual Property, stated in an announcement. “Ms. Karan wants to repair it earlier than somebody will get harm.”
Karan’s authorized crew is now transferring to dismiss Gottlieb’s go well with. Not solely is the Gottlieb case redundant with City Zen’s personal go well with, however particulars included about Karan’s litigation historical past quantity to harassment of a public determine, they argue.
“This movement arises from a clear act of litigation warfare,” Karen’s attorneys wrote in a memo. “The choice to call [Karan] personally (by full title, within the caption, in a property dispute by which she individually holds no possession curiosity within the topic property and by which no cognizable foundation for private legal responsibility is alleged) will not be a mirrored image of authorized necessity. It’s a reflection of the worth of her title as a reputational goal.”
Natraj Bhushan, an legal professional for Karen with Turturro Legislation, known as the Gottlieb go well with “meritless,” and “retaliatory,” saying the declare towards Karan personally was “plainly frivolous.”
Barowitz, the Gottlieb spokesperson, reiterated that the situation of City Zen’s constructing is a menace to neighbors. “Hiding behind baseless allegations of SLAPP litigation is disgraceful,” he stated in an announcement.
William Gottlieb Actual Property is the eponymous agency of a prolific downtown property proprietor who compiled an expansive portfolio earlier than his demise in 1999 at 64. He purchased greater than 100 properties, the New York Times reported, most of them within the Meatpacking District and the far west aspect of the Village, however hardly ever bought. His sister, Mollie Bender, took over the enterprise till her demise in 2007, according to amNY.
Gottlieb bought 703 Greenwich Road in 1966, in line with metropolis data. Bender and Gottlieb’s property transferred the property to an LLC in 2006.
Learn extra
“Garbage dump”: Donna Karan brand sues neighbor over rat infestation
