Considered one of final yr’s priciest offers within the Hamptons has grow to be the centerpiece of ongoing litigation.
The lawsuit, filed by Sotheby’s Worldwide in opposition to the vendor Nancy Silverman and her LLC, surrounds the $56 million sale of 1010 Meadow Lane in Southampton to beforehand unreported purchaser Roger Barnett, CEO of the pure diet firm Shaklee.
Sotheby’s claims that Silverman — who was married to personal fairness govt and founding father of 54 Madison Companions, Henry Silverman till their divorce in 2012 — stiffed them of $840,000 in fee charges, refusing to pay for the providers of Sotheby’s dealer Harald Grant.
Grant started engaged on the itemizing in Could 2025, the grievance states. Sotheby’s and Silverman signed a list settlement in July, establishing a 1.5% fee. Sotheby’s had an unique proper to promote the property till January 2026.
Bespoke Actual Property president and co-founder Cody Vichinsky notified Grant of Barnett as a potential purchaser in July, based on the agent’s affidavit. Barnett then contacted Silverman straight, however Grant continued to handle the transaction, at one level stopping the deal from falling via, authorized filings state.
Silverman complained to Grant that Barnett was “not shifting quick sufficient” in closing the deal and directed the agent to place the property again in the marketplace to hunt different consumers.
“I endorsed Ms. Silverman that Mr. Barnett was doubtless potential purchaser for the Property who she shouldn’t lose in haste,” Grant wrote in affirmation. “…I suggested Mr. Barnett that the property can be again in the marketplace if he didn’t conform to Ms. Silverman’s calls for. Because of my dialog with him, Mr. Barnett agreed to all of Ms. Silverman’s calls for, and the transaction was in a position to transfer ahead once more.”
Grant says his administration not solely “salvaged the deal,” but additionally secured Silverman an extra $1,000,000 for furnishings and fixtures. The sale was closed in August with possession transferred to company entities related to Barnett. Silverman refused to compensate Sotheby’s for any of its providers.
The sale at 1010 Meadow Lane was sixth on The Real Deal’s list of the priciest Hamptons deals of 2025.
Barnett and his spouse, lawyer and journalist Sloan Barnett, acquired a waterfront mansion in Miami in 2021 for $38 million. In January, the couple offered one other waterfront mansion they purchased in 2021, in Miami’s Coconut Grove neighborhood for $71.9 million — over 60 p.c greater than their buy worth.
Sotheby’s filed the go well with within the Supreme Court docket of the State of New York, County of New York. The defendants have since retained counsel and filed a movement to dismiss the grievance.
Harald Grant and Joshua Schiller, protection counsel representing Silverman and 1010 Meadow LLC, didn’t instantly return a request for remark.
Learn extra
The 10 priciest residential deals in the Hamptons in 2025
Residential
South Florida
Vitamin maker and Lindemann heiress revealed as purchasers of Star Island estate for $38M: sources
Residential
South Florida
Nutrition guru couple pays $17M for Fisher Island condo
